Question 1316) - The owner instructed the Muda' not to give the wadi'ah to his wife. He gave it to her. or he instructed him, ?Guard it in this room," he then guarded it in another room of the same house. The Wadi'ah perished. Is he liable?

A: Not in these cases. If however he left it at another house he is liable.

~ al-Quduri ~