Question 2182) - A man claims an item from another. The mudda?a ?alayhi says, ?This item a third party left as Wadi'ah/ Rahn by me/ I usurped it from a third party." What is the ruling?

A: If the mudda'a 'alayhi can produce evidence to that effect then the dispute between them will no longer be entertained.

~ al-Quduri ~