Question 2186) - A house is in the possession of a man. A second man claims that the entire house is his. A third man claims that half the house is his. Both produce evidence. What is the ruling?

A: According to Imaam Abu Hanifah RAH. the second man gets three-quarters and the third man gets a quarter. According to Imaam Abu YusufRAH. and Imaam Muhammed RAH. he Second gets two-thirds and the third gets a third.

~ al-Quduri ~