If the mudda'a 'alayhi however says, "I bought it from a third party," does the claim of the mudda'i remain? Print
Kitabud Da'wa [Claims] - Definition

Question 2183) - If the mudda'a 'alayhi however says, "I bought it from a third party," does the claim of the mudda'i remain?

A: Yes.*

* Because the mudda'a 'alayhi has in effect acknowledged that the claimant had ownership in the item.

~ al-Quduri ~