|
I do not understand. Please explain by way of an example. |
 |
 |
 |
|
Question 420) - I do not understand. Please explain by way of an example.
A: Ponder over this example carefully. A man has 9 camels over which a complete year has passed. 4 then were destroyed' He must pay a complete sheep, just as if there had been no excess over 5. Thedestroyed 4 are overlooked as normal excess in which Zakah in not paid until the camels reach 10. This is according to Imaam Abu Hanifa RAH. and Imaam Abu Yusuf RAH.
According to Imaam Muhammed RAH. and Imaam Zufar RAH. he has to pay S-ninths of a sheep. They have spread the wajib across the 9 camels and proportionately decreased the loss over the nine.
A second example: A man has 80 goats of which 40 were destroyed after the year. According to Imaam Abu Hanifa RAH. and Imaam Abu yusuf RAH. a sheep is due on the remainder. According to the others, a half sheep.
lf 60 were destroyed then a half is due according to Imaam Abu Hanifa RAH. and Imaam Abu Yusuf RAH. and a quarter according to the others. [See Fathul Qadir, al-'Inayah and al-Jawharah an-Nayyirah]
~ al-Quduri ~ |
|
|
lf the Nisab remains but the non-Zakatable excess has been destroyed, is Zakah calculated on the entire remainder or is it decreased in proportion to the destroyed wealth? |
|
|
|
|
Question 419) - lf the Nisab remains but the non-Zakatable excess has been destroyed, is Zakah calculated on the entire remainder or is it decreased in proportion to the destroyed wealth?
A: The principle according to Imaam Abu Hanifa RAH. and Imaam Abu yusuf RAH. is that Zakah is Wajib on the Nisab not the excess. Hence the wajib is intact according to them. According to Imaam Muhammed RAH. and Imaam Zufar RAH. Wajib deceases in proportion to the loss.
~ al-Quduri ~ |
|
What does the Zakaat-collector do if he does not find in the herd what must be taken? |
|
|
|
|
Question 417) - What does the Zakaat-collector do if he does not find in the herd what must be taken?
A: He will take a lesser animal and more to equal the amount due, or he will take a higher animal and pay the difference back.
~ al-Quduri ~ |
|
|
Should the collector take the best wealth or worst? |
|
|
|
|
Question 418) - Should the collector take the best wealth or worst?
A: He should take something in between.
NOTE: It is impermissible in the Zakah of camels to take males, such as a male in its second year except for the purpose of evaluating a female. [al-Bahr ar- Raiq (230/2)]
~ al-Quduri ~ |
|
What does Imaam Abu Hanifa RAH. say about the offspring of camels and cattle? |
|
|
|
|
Question 416) - What does Imaam Abu Hanifa RAH. say about the offspring of camels and cattle?
A: There is no Zakah on the babies of camels, sheep and goats according to Imaam Abu Hanifa RAH. and Imaam Muhammed RAH. unless they are with adults. It is wajib according to Imaam Abu Yusuf RAH. [There are further details to his view which can be read in al-Hidayah].
~ al-Quduri ~ |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Page 859 of 943 |
